As I already commented, I think the numbers here are such that the post should be considered quite important even though I agree that it fails at establishing that fish can suffer (and perhaps lacks comparison to fish in the wild). If there was another post with a more nuanced stance on this point, I’d vote for that one instead, but there isn’t. I think fish wellbeing should be part of the conversation more than it is right now.
It’s also very unpleasant to think or write about these things, so I’m also more willing to overlook flaws than I’d be by default.
As I already commented, I think the numbers here are such that the post should be considered quite important even though I agree that it fails at establishing that fish can suffer (and perhaps lacks comparison to fish in the wild). If there was another post with a more nuanced stance on this point, I’d vote for that one instead, but there isn’t. I think fish wellbeing should be part of the conversation more than it is right now.
It’s also very unpleasant to think or write about these things, so I’m also more willing to overlook flaws than I’d be by default.