I’m not sure how you’re addressing what I said. What do you mean by escaping vacuity? I used “good for them” in that comment because you did, when you said that not everything people value is good for them. I agree with that, if you mean the particular values that people have, but not in regard to their fundamental values.
Saying that something is morally good means “doing this thing, after considering all the factors, is good for me,” and saying that it is morally bad means “doing this thing, after considering all the factors, is bad for me.” Of course something might be somewhat good, without being morally good, because it is good according to some factors, but not after considering all of them. And of course whether or not it will benefit your communities is one of the factors.
I’m not sure how you’re addressing what I said. What do you mean by escaping vacuity? I used “good for them” in that comment because you did, when you said that not everything people value is good for them. I agree with that, if you mean the particular values that people have, but not in regard to their fundamental values.
Saying that something is morally good means “doing this thing, after considering all the factors, is good for me,” and saying that it is morally bad means “doing this thing, after considering all the factors, is bad for me.” Of course something might be somewhat good, without being morally good, because it is good according to some factors, but not after considering all of them. And of course whether or not it will benefit your communities is one of the factors.