The opposite of obedient to authority is not “psychopath”, it’s “troublemaker”.
It looks as if you’re responding to JM4 as if he’s claiming “it’s OK to have laws requiring babies to be tweaked for obedience to authority, because that’s how we avoid getting psychopaths”. But it looks to me as if he’s actually claiming “There won’t be laws requiring babies to be tweaked for obedience to authority—the populace wouldn’t stand for it. What there might be is laws requiring them to be tweaked for not-being-psychopaths, and that would be OK”.
It’s perfectly reasonable to be concerned that what there would actually be is a law called the Psychopathy Prevention Act whose text, when read carefully, in fact requires babies to be tweaked for obedience to authority. But if indeed that’s what would happen then JM4′s problem is not that he approves of enforcing obedience to authority but that he is making a wrong prediction about future politics.
I mostly have slippery slope concerns here. Once you’ve given the government the right to choose some—any—characteristics of your children, I fear the list of these characteristics can only expand.
It looks as if you’re responding to JM4 as if he’s claiming “it’s OK to have laws requiring babies to be tweaked for obedience to authority, because that’s how we avoid getting psychopaths”. But it looks to me as if he’s actually claiming “There won’t be laws requiring babies to be tweaked for obedience to authority—the populace wouldn’t stand for it. What there might be is laws requiring them to be tweaked for not-being-psychopaths, and that would be OK”.
It’s perfectly reasonable to be concerned that what there would actually be is a law called the Psychopathy Prevention Act whose text, when read carefully, in fact requires babies to be tweaked for obedience to authority. But if indeed that’s what would happen then JM4′s problem is not that he approves of enforcing obedience to authority but that he is making a wrong prediction about future politics.
I mostly have slippery slope concerns here. Once you’ve given the government the right to choose some—any—characteristics of your children, I fear the list of these characteristics can only expand.