Laws don’t implement themselves: people within corporations design frameworks and strategies so that implementation of these laws is operationally possible.
NIS-2 seems to be going in the same direction. My point is, the AI knowledge/alignment problem is much bigger because implementation is squishy and complex.
I’d love it if you did a “diss” style of this post (like you did that one time on Substack) explaining how all of this really depends on regulatory action being credible, courts understanding what they’re dealing with etc. Lesswrong folk seem to care, seeing how many up votes the Quicktake got! 🙏
Also, regulators and courts enforce the laws. That’s where the real ‘implementation’ comes in. A law without teeth for state-sanctioned coercion is toothless and won’t get implemented at all. Just look at the Platform to Business Regulation (EU 2019/1150). Few companies know it exists; fewer still bother to do what’s required under the law. https://www.maverick-law.com/en/blogs/platform-to-business-regulation-more-rights-for-business-users-of-online-platforms.html
NIS-2 seems to be going in the same direction. My point is, the AI knowledge/alignment problem is much bigger because implementation is squishy and complex.
I’d love it if you did a “diss” style of this post (like you did that one time on Substack) explaining how all of this really depends on regulatory action being credible, courts understanding what they’re dealing with etc. Lesswrong folk seem to care, seeing how many up votes the Quicktake got! 🙏
Yes, but I like you, so it wouldn’t be a diss-take. I only reserve the spicy stuff for my sworn enemies.