As of now, the votes are positive. I guess it sometimes happens that some people like your comment, some people don’t like it, and the ones who don’t like it just noticed it first.
(By the way, I mostly agree with the spirit of your comment, but I think you used too strong words. So I didn’t vote either way. For example, as mentioned elsewhere, a good reason to wait for a week might be that the “context” is someone else’s words, and you want to get their consent to publish the record. Also, the conclusion that “the Nonlinear side seems pretty fishy” is like… yeah, I suppose that most readers feel the same, but the debate is precisely about whether Nonlinear can produce in a week some context that will make it seem “less fishy”. They would probably agree that the text as it is written now does not put them in good light.)
As of now, the votes are positive. I guess it sometimes happens that some people like your comment, some people don’t like it, and the ones who don’t like it just noticed it first.
(By the way, I mostly agree with the spirit of your comment, but I think you used too strong words. So I didn’t vote either way. For example, as mentioned elsewhere, a good reason to wait for a week might be that the “context” is someone else’s words, and you want to get their consent to publish the record. Also, the conclusion that “the Nonlinear side seems pretty fishy” is like… yeah, I suppose that most readers feel the same, but the debate is precisely about whether Nonlinear can produce in a week some context that will make it seem “less fishy”. They would probably agree that the text as it is written now does not put them in good light.)