I specifically said weakly dominant “in terms of protecting yourself”, and pointed out that the case for blue depends on a form of altruism (“the only reason to choose blue is to rescue the other people who chose blue”). Please exercise better reading comprehension.
I agree that the random-death variation would make it vastly easier to coordinate on blue. The reason the dilemma is so controversial is because the perception of what other people will or should do is so susceptible to framing effects. It’s a lot easier to coordinate on red in the blender variation.
I specifically said weakly dominant “in terms of protecting yourself”, and pointed out that the case for blue depends on a form of altruism (“the only reason to choose blue is to rescue the other people who chose blue”). Please exercise better reading comprehension.
I agree that the random-death variation would make it vastly easier to coordinate on blue. The reason the dilemma is so controversial is because the perception of what other people will or should do is so susceptible to framing effects. It’s a lot easier to coordinate on red in the blender variation.