Looking at Augustine’s taxonomy the terminology seems clearer, as it differentiates “lies told to please others in smooth discourse,” which is what I think Alicorn would associate with ‘white lies,’ with “lies that harm no one and that protect someone from bodily defilement.” (And note how the lies in religious teachings mirrors the discussion of lies in science!) As expected, Augustine thinks it’s better to lie to the Nazi than to lie to your aunt.
But again it seems the subjectivity shines through in the definition of harm, if you want to put the hidden Jew lie in Augustine’s last category. Isn’t the Nazi harmed when you lie to him, and he doesn’t get to catch the hidden Jew?
Looking at Augustine’s taxonomy the terminology seems clearer, as it differentiates “lies told to please others in smooth discourse,” which is what I think Alicorn would associate with ‘white lies,’ with “lies that harm no one and that protect someone from bodily defilement.” (And note how the lies in religious teachings mirrors the discussion of lies in science!) As expected, Augustine thinks it’s better to lie to the Nazi than to lie to your aunt.
But again it seems the subjectivity shines through in the definition of harm, if you want to put the hidden Jew lie in Augustine’s last category. Isn’t the Nazi harmed when you lie to him, and he doesn’t get to catch the hidden Jew?
most people WANT the nazi to be harmed.
Indeed.
I would argue that the Nazi isn’t really harmed when you lie to him, because not having a preference satisfied is not necessarily harm.