Your discussion of Harris’s ‘Lying’ is a little terse, and does miss some of his arguments. I think anyone interested should get his book, its very short and can be read in about half an hour to an hour, depending on your speed. PM me for a PDF copy of the first edition (note: second edition is much updated).
Here’s two extended quotes, that I think contains ideas not addressed in the post:
Once one commits to telling the truth, one begins to notice how unusual it is to meet someone who shares this commitment. Honest people are a refuge: You know they mean what they say; you know they will not say one thing to your face and another behind your back; you know they will tell you when they think you have failed—and for this reason their praise cannot be mistaken for mere flattery.
Honesty is a gift we can give to others. It is also a source of power and an engine of simplicity. Knowing that we will attempt to tell the truth, whatever the circumstances, leaves us with little to prepare for. We can simply be ourselves.
In committing to be honest with everyone, we commit to avoiding a wide range of long-term problems, but at the cost of occasional, short-term discom- fort. However, the discomfort should not be exaggerated: You can be honest and kind, because your purpose in telling the truth is not to offend people: You simply want them to have the information you have, and would want to have if you were in their position.
But it can take practice to feel comfortable with this way of being in the world—to cancel plans, decline invitations, critique others’ work, etc., all while being honest about what one is thinking and feeling. To do this is also to hold a mirror up to one’s life—because a commitment to telling the truth requires that one pay attention to what the truth is in every moment. What sort of person are you? How judgmental, self-interested, or petty have you become?
...
But let’s imagine the truth is harder to tell: Your friend looks fat in that dress, or any dress, because she is fat. Let’s say she is also thirty-five years old and single, and you happen to know that her greatest desire at this moment in life is to get married and start a family. You believe that many men might be disinclined to date her at her current weight. And, marriage aside, you are confident that she would be happier and healthier, and would feel better about herself, if she got in shape.
A white lie is simply a denial of these realities. It is a refusal to offer honest guidance in a storm. Even on so touchy a subject, lying seems a clear failure of friendship. By reassuring your friend about her appearance, you are not helping her to do what you think she should do to get what she wants out of life… …False encouragement is a kind of theft: it steals time, energy, and motivation a person could put toward some other purpose.
But let’s imagine the truth is harder to tell: Your friend looks fat in that dress, or any dress, because she is fat. Let’s say she is also thirty-five years old and single, and you happen to know that her greatest desire at this moment in life is to get married and start a family. . . . By reassuring your friend about her appearance, you are not helping her to do what you think she should do to get what she wants out of life… …False encouragement is a kind of theft: it steals time, energy, and motivation a person could put toward some other purpose.
That’s an interesting example, because in her more reflective moments, the friend is almost certainly already aware that she is fat and that it makes her significantly less sexually attractive. She is probably reminded of this unpleasant truth on a regular basis and it’s not entirely clear that an additional reminder will be helpful. She has probably tried at least 10 or 15 diets and they have all failed.
If you are considering reminding a fat person that they are fat, you need to ask yourself what your motivations are for doing something which (1) will certainly cause short-term emotional pain; and (2) is unlikely to result in the person getting their shit together and losing the weight. Are you really trying to help them? Or are you just trying to make yourself feel superior at their expense?
My impression is that there are a lot of “concerned” people who are happy to give free advice to fatties (often something along the lines of “eat less and exercise more—you’re killing yourself”) but unwilling to give $20 or $30 towards a gym membership for said fatties. This suggests that often the motivation is more status-mongering than actual concern.
Whatever the value in being honest with other people, I suspect there is more value in being honest with yourself.
If you are considering reminding a fat person that they are fat, you need to ask yourself what your motivations are for doing something which (1) will certainly cause short-term emotional pain; and (2) is unlikely to result in the person getting their shit together and losing the weight. Are you really trying to help them? Or are you just trying to make yourself feel superior at their expense?
Remember that we’re discussing a case where the person asked you for your opinion. I certainly wouldn’t just randomly say to someone “Hey, guess what? You’re fat”, especially if that person was my friend or someone else I cared about.
But if they asked me? That’s a different story altogether.
My impression is that there are a lot of “concerned” people who are happy to give free advice to fatties (often something along the lines of “eat less and exercise more—you’re killing yourself”) but unwilling to give $20 or $30 towards a gym membership for said fatties. This suggests that often the motivation is more status-mongering than actual concern.
Do you really think this is the case for good friends, or loved ones? Unwilling to give $20 or $30, really? And furthermore, do you in fact believe that not having the money for a gym membership is the important obstacle between an overweight person and an effective weight-less solution?
Remember that we’re discussing a case where the person asked you for your opinion.
The quoted hypothetical doesn’t make clear if the information is asked for or volunteered. Nor does it make clear what it would mean to tell the truth: “Yes, that dress makes you look fat.”; “That dress makes you look fat because you look fat in any dress because you’re fat”; “You look fat in any dress and that’s why men are not interested in you”; or something else.
Do you really think this is the case for good friends, or loved ones?
Probably not . . . but I don’t think it affects my point, which is that a lot of the time, people express concern, and might even believe that they are acting out of concern, but actually they have other motivations.
And furthermore, do you in fact believe that not having the money for a gym membership is the important obstacle between an overweight person and an effective weight-less solution?
No I don’t. But I’m skeptical that the lack of an additional reminder is an obstacle either.
Your discussion of Harris’s ‘Lying’ is a little terse, and does miss some of his arguments. I think anyone interested should get his book, its very short and can be read in about half an hour to an hour, depending on your speed. PM me for a PDF copy of the first edition (note: second edition is much updated).
Here’s two extended quotes, that I think contains ideas not addressed in the post:
...
That’s an interesting example, because in her more reflective moments, the friend is almost certainly already aware that she is fat and that it makes her significantly less sexually attractive. She is probably reminded of this unpleasant truth on a regular basis and it’s not entirely clear that an additional reminder will be helpful. She has probably tried at least 10 or 15 diets and they have all failed.
If you are considering reminding a fat person that they are fat, you need to ask yourself what your motivations are for doing something which (1) will certainly cause short-term emotional pain; and (2) is unlikely to result in the person getting their shit together and losing the weight. Are you really trying to help them? Or are you just trying to make yourself feel superior at their expense?
My impression is that there are a lot of “concerned” people who are happy to give free advice to fatties (often something along the lines of “eat less and exercise more—you’re killing yourself”) but unwilling to give $20 or $30 towards a gym membership for said fatties. This suggests that often the motivation is more status-mongering than actual concern.
Whatever the value in being honest with other people, I suspect there is more value in being honest with yourself.
Remember that we’re discussing a case where the person asked you for your opinion. I certainly wouldn’t just randomly say to someone “Hey, guess what? You’re fat”, especially if that person was my friend or someone else I cared about.
But if they asked me? That’s a different story altogether.
Do you really think this is the case for good friends, or loved ones? Unwilling to give $20 or $30, really? And furthermore, do you in fact believe that not having the money for a gym membership is the important obstacle between an overweight person and an effective weight-less solution?
The quoted hypothetical doesn’t make clear if the information is asked for or volunteered. Nor does it make clear what it would mean to tell the truth: “Yes, that dress makes you look fat.”; “That dress makes you look fat because you look fat in any dress because you’re fat”; “You look fat in any dress and that’s why men are not interested in you”; or something else.
Probably not . . . but I don’t think it affects my point, which is that a lot of the time, people express concern, and might even believe that they are acting out of concern, but actually they have other motivations.
No I don’t. But I’m skeptical that the lack of an additional reminder is an obstacle either.