I admire how you’ve identified your reaction as a mindkill response.
It’s not that hard. If you feel adrenaline/indignance/anger at a Less Wrong comment and/or a compulsive urge to reply then the prior should be that you’ve been mindkilled, since when one takes the outside view people on LW tend to be a pretty reasonable bunch.
Are we in agreement about this?
I am in agreement with your points as I interpret their statement. I am not sure my interpretation of the statements agrees with yours. For example, what do you mean by “not make excuses to dominate one another”? There are many situations (governments, chain-of-command in workplaces, employers) where people can legitimately dominate one another, if that’s what you mean by dominate.
Because I have barely read any of the writing by “Guardian comment section class warfare types” …
Would you mind explaining these two sides?
Sure. I’ll PM you, since I don’t think a detailed description of British politics is very relevant. :)
The point that is relevant is that I’m not defending what you’re calling elitism, nor do I frequently call myself elitist, I’m just opposing people who oppose elitism, since when they use that word the definition tends to include me.
What I meant was just that it’s pleasant to see that someone else was doing that. I didn’t expect it. I know I’m capable of doing that, too. I am beginning to wonder about my response to the elitism thing. I’m asking myself questions like “Would I have responded differently if I was not upset?” and “If so, why did I let being upset influence my reaction to this specifically, when I know I can prevent it from influencing me on other things?”
The point that is relevant is that I’m not defending what you’re calling elitism, nor do I frequently call myself elitist, I’m just opposing people who oppose elitism, since when they use that word the definition tends to include me.
Oh. I didn’t think of the possibility of you being lumped into that outside of your control.
That’s a good point and makes the situation more complex.
Back to the “two sides”—I don’t really want to be on one side or the other. I want to understand both. There’s got to be a way for both sides to get along with each other. It’s a problem worth solving. Do you think a lot of LessWrongers would agree with these statements, or do you think they’re too entrenched in mindkill?
It’s not that hard. If you feel adrenaline/indignance/anger at a Less Wrong comment and/or a compulsive urge to reply then the prior should be that you’ve been mindkilled, since when one takes the outside view people on LW tend to be a pretty reasonable bunch.
I am in agreement with your points as I interpret their statement. I am not sure my interpretation of the statements agrees with yours. For example, what do you mean by “not make excuses to dominate one another”? There are many situations (governments, chain-of-command in workplaces, employers) where people can legitimately dominate one another, if that’s what you mean by dominate.
Sure. I’ll PM you, since I don’t think a detailed description of British politics is very relevant. :)
The point that is relevant is that I’m not defending what you’re calling elitism, nor do I frequently call myself elitist, I’m just opposing people who oppose elitism, since when they use that word the definition tends to include me.
What I meant was just that it’s pleasant to see that someone else was doing that. I didn’t expect it. I know I’m capable of doing that, too. I am beginning to wonder about my response to the elitism thing. I’m asking myself questions like “Would I have responded differently if I was not upset?” and “If so, why did I let being upset influence my reaction to this specifically, when I know I can prevent it from influencing me on other things?”
Oh. I didn’t think of the possibility of you being lumped into that outside of your control.
That’s a good point and makes the situation more complex.
Back to the “two sides”—I don’t really want to be on one side or the other. I want to understand both. There’s got to be a way for both sides to get along with each other. It’s a problem worth solving. Do you think a lot of LessWrongers would agree with these statements, or do you think they’re too entrenched in mindkill?