what kinds of arguments should even be used in this debate?
Ok, now we have a reasonable question. I don’t know, but I provided two argument-sketches that I think are of a potentially relevant type. At an abstract level, the answer would be “mathematico-conceptual reasoning”, just like in all previous instances where there’s a thing that has never happened before, and yet we reason somewhat successfully about it—of which there are plenty examples, if you think about it for a minute.
Ok, now we have a reasonable question. I don’t know, but I provided two argument-sketches that I think are of a potentially relevant type. At an abstract level, the answer would be “mathematico-conceptual reasoning”, just like in all previous instances where there’s a thing that has never happened before, and yet we reason somewhat successfully about it—of which there are plenty examples, if you think about it for a minute.