That’s not a bad idea. You could link something like “this post is a reply to X” and then people could explore “threads” of posts that are all rebuttals and arguments surrounding a single specific topic. Doesn’t even need to be about things that have gotten this hostile, sometimes you just want to write a full post because it’s more organic than a comment.
Right. I realized later that I framed this as something the commenter decides; it would also be possible to have this sort of thing replace authors deleting comments or ban users. The author could press the “boot” button, and then this boots the comment out of the comment section. But it doesn’t delete it, it just moves all discussion to wherever the comment was booted to (e.g. open thread or quick take or something). Maybe it also hides most of the comment, and shows a single response from the author. (Not especially advocating for this.)
That’s not a bad idea. You could link something like “this post is a reply to X” and then people could explore “threads” of posts that are all rebuttals and arguments surrounding a single specific topic. Doesn’t even need to be about things that have gotten this hostile, sometimes you just want to write a full post because it’s more organic than a comment.
Right. I realized later that I framed this as something the commenter decides; it would also be possible to have this sort of thing replace authors deleting comments or ban users. The author could press the “boot” button, and then this boots the comment out of the comment section. But it doesn’t delete it, it just moves all discussion to wherever the comment was booted to (e.g. open thread or quick take or something). Maybe it also hides most of the comment, and shows a single response from the author. (Not especially advocating for this.)