Coming to this comment late, but off the cuff takes:
Seems good.
Unclear to me if the decisionmaking friction of implementing this now is worth the costs; agree there are some worlds where you want to do it when things really heat up.
Not a lawyer but my guess is that there’s no way to do this which doesn’t let the US legal system access the recordings before 10y are up in the event of litigation.
Kinda torn on this; I think this is what organizations in a sane world should do, but on actual Earth I don’t know if it’s worth the weirdness points. I care a lot about Anthropic spending down its credibility as a normal serious organization on actions that have a low ROI, and I think the audience that would actually understand and respect this in the right way is pretty small.
This sort of stuff generally seems good, haven’t thought about the doc’s particular proposal in detail. I think stuff like welfare reports in the Claude 4 model card are moving in this direction already.
Agree you want this option, not sure what concrete actions you think would be good besides “think about the fact that you might do this”?
Yep, would happy about more of this on the margin.
I think as of June 2025 A\ has basically done this?
Coming to this comment late, but off the cuff takes:
Seems good.
Unclear to me if the decisionmaking friction of implementing this now is worth the costs; agree there are some worlds where you want to do it when things really heat up.
Not a lawyer but my guess is that there’s no way to do this which doesn’t let the US legal system access the recordings before 10y are up in the event of litigation.
Kinda torn on this; I think this is what organizations in a sane world should do, but on actual Earth I don’t know if it’s worth the weirdness points. I care a lot about Anthropic spending down its credibility as a normal serious organization on actions that have a low ROI, and I think the audience that would actually understand and respect this in the right way is pretty small.
This sort of stuff generally seems good, haven’t thought about the doc’s particular proposal in detail. I think stuff like welfare reports in the Claude 4 model card are moving in this direction already.
Agree you want this option, not sure what concrete actions you think would be good besides “think about the fact that you might do this”?
Yep, would happy about more of this on the margin.
I think as of June 2025 A\ has basically done this?
Agree this would be good.