That is a fair point, since virtue is tied to your identity and self it is a lot easier to take things personally and therefore distort the truth.
A part of me is like “meh, skill issue, just get good at emotional intelligence and see through your self” but that is probably not a very valid solution at scale if I’m being honest.
There’s still something nice about it leading to repeated games and similar, something about how if you look at our past then cooperation arises from repeated games rather than individual games where you analyse things in detail. This is the specific point that Joshua Greene makes in his Moral Tribes book for example.
Maybe the core point here is not virtue versus utilitarian reasoning, it might more be about the ease of self-deception and how different time limits and how ways of evaluating your own outcomes and outputs should be done in a more impersonal way. Maybe one shouldn’t call this virtue ethics as it carries a large bag and camp, maybe heruistics ethics or something (though that feels stupid).
That is a fair point, since virtue is tied to your identity and self it is a lot easier to take things personally and therefore distort the truth.
A part of me is like “meh, skill issue, just get good at emotional intelligence and see through your self” but that is probably not a very valid solution at scale if I’m being honest.
There’s still something nice about it leading to repeated games and similar, something about how if you look at our past then cooperation arises from repeated games rather than individual games where you analyse things in detail. This is the specific point that Joshua Greene makes in his Moral Tribes book for example.
Maybe the core point here is not virtue versus utilitarian reasoning, it might more be about the ease of self-deception and how different time limits and how ways of evaluating your own outcomes and outputs should be done in a more impersonal way. Maybe one shouldn’t call this virtue ethics as it carries a large bag and camp, maybe heruistics ethics or something (though that feels stupid).