The idea is that the universe offers you Dutch-book situations
But does it in fact do that? To the extent that you believe that humans are bad Bayesians, you believe that the environment in which humans evolved wasn’t constantly Dutch-booking them, or that if it was then humans evolved some defense against this which isn’t becoming perfect Bayesians.
I do suspect that our thousand shards of desire being contradictory and not resolving is selected for, in that we are thus money-pumped into propagating our genes.
But does it in fact do that? To the extent that you believe that humans are bad Bayesians, you believe that the environment in which humans evolved wasn’t constantly Dutch-booking them, or that if it was then humans evolved some defense against this which isn’t becoming perfect Bayesians.
I do suspect that our thousand shards of desire being contradictory and not resolving is selected for, in that we are thus money-pumped into propagating our genes.