Humans have these things that we call goals. They also take these things called actions. Ideally, a human takes actions that move the world closer to one of the human’s goals. You want your actions to be connected to your goals in this sense.
Usually, when an action is first introduced into your action repertoire, it has a very clear connection to your goal. However, once an action is introduced, it often tends to stick around. Sometimes, the action-goal connection doesn’t change, and so continuing to take that action is a good idea. Other times, the action-goal connection shifts, but you still continue to take that action.
The purpose of goal factoring is two fold. The first purpose is to evaluate the strength of the action goal connection for any given action. The second purpose is to find actions that have a stronger connection to your goals.
Cleaning your closet
Closets can have many things inside them. The closet I will discuss today contains all of your goals. However, you can’t just put stuff in a closet willy nilly, it must be organized in boxes. The boxes that you put your goals in are your actions.
We proceed as if we are cleaning a regular closet. First, we pick a box. Then we open the box. Sometimes, we realize that the box is way too big for the thing inside it, so we find a smaller box. Sometimes, we don’t even want the stuff, so we throw it away. Other times, we find that the stuff fits pretty well inside the box, so we leave it as it is. Goal factoring is the process of opening the action-box to find the goals inside.
In terms of action-goal connection, the first case corresponds to a case where the action is an ineffective way to achieve the goal. For example, suppose my goal is to stay up to date with current events and my action is browsing Reddit for hours a day. It seems evident that there are ways that will keep me both better informed about current events and take less time than browsing Reddit.
The second case corresponds to goals shifting as time passes. For example, I used to value having up-to-date information about Magic: the Gathering, resulting in me checking various MtG websites quite frequently. However, recently I discovered that I no longer really cared what was happening in the MtG world, yet I continued to check the websites.
The third case is when the action-goal connection remains strong. For example, I have a goal of not having my teeth fall out and I take the action of brushing my teeth. It seems to me that brushing my teeth is one of the best ways to not have your teeth fall out, so I continue to brush my teeth.
Steps
Here’s a diagram I stole from the CFAR handbook about a good visual way to follow these steps
Pick an action.
Write down all the goals that the action moves you towards
Many people have goals that aren’t quite socially desirable. It’s important to write these too.
For example, one of my goals for “going to the gym” is to become more attractive.
Completeness check: check if you’ve written down all the goals is to pretend that you already have everything you’ve written down in abundance. If you’ve written down all the goals, then you should feel no desire to perform the action any more.
Write down all the goals that the action moves you away from
Again, it’s important to write down everything, even stuff like “makes me look like a weirdo” and “don’t like talking to people”.
Removal check: check if you’ve written everything down by pretending that the action doesn’t move you away from any of those goals. If you’ve written everything down, then you should feel like taking the action is correct.
Remember that things like “takes time” are goals that almost all actions move you away from and that you should write those things down.
Decide if the goals you’ve written are crucial to that action.
This can be done by seeing how much your desire to take the action changes if you varied the magnitude of how much the action affected that goal.
In math language, a goal is crucial if the derivative of action desire w.r.t. action goal connection strength has large magnitude.
Example: “takes time” is probably not crucial to “brushing your teeth” because I would still brush my teeth if it took double the time.
Example: For me, “looking better” was not crucial to “going to the gym” because I would still go to the gym even if it made me look slightly worse.
Example : For me, “acquiring new experiences” was not crucial to “getting my ears pierced” because I wouldn’t extremely want to get my ears pierced if the experience was twice as unique.
Brainstorm other actions that achieve the goals you’ve written while avoiding the costs.
If the box you open has many goals inside, you can replace the single action with a lot of smaller action-boxes
Imagine taking those actions instead of the action you’re currently goal factoring. Are there any other goals that those actions move you away from? Are there any goals that those actions don’t move you towards?
Decide which set of actions to take, iterating (3) if necessary.
Example: Learning Chinese
My parents speak both Chinese and English. My extended family pretty much only speaks Chinese. My current level of Chinese is passable, but sorely lacking. As of 2 weeks ago, I had spent the past month or so studying Chinese for 10 minutes every day. Here’s what I goal factored:
Goals learning Chinese moved me towards:
Parental approval
Communicating with extended family
Want to be able to think in a different language
Social status boost from being bilingual
Career prospects increased from being bilingual
Goals learning Chinese moved me away from:
Takes time
Takes attention
I don’t like learning languages/memorizing things
I don’t like doing things I’m not good at
After considering which goals were crucial, the list ended up looking like:
Goals learning Chinese moved me towards:
Communicating with extended family
Want to be able to think in a different language
Goals learning Chinese moved me away from:
Takes time
Takes attention
Brainstorming ideas, I noted that “thinking in a different language” could be achieved by learning a non-Chinese language. In fact, it seemed like learning a language like ASL that uses a different channel of communication might be much better at achieving this goal than learning Chinese.
However, since my extended family pretty much only speaks Chinese, it seemed like “learning Chinese” was the best action to accomplish that particular goal. At this point I just had to weigh the time/attention it costs to learn Chinese versus how much I wanted to be able to communicate with my extended family.
This is what I ended up with:
This process is a lot like just writing a pro/cons list. Although plain pro/con lists are more useful than people give them credit for, I think that the crucial addition is trying to figure out different actions to take to get what you want.
Remember, the point of goal factoring is not to pick and action and convince yourself that it’s a good/bad action. Keep your bottom line empty.
Exercise
Pick an action and goal factor it. Places to look for actions that might be good to goal factor are actions that you started taking a long time ago, actions that take a lot of time, and actions that you don’t often think about because they’re very small. The latter case is relevant because lots of small actions can pile up and end up sucking away a lot of your time/attention.
One way to think about applied rationality is trying to achieve your goals while staying agnostic about the strategy. Goal factoring is a tool that helps you do that.
Training Regime Day 7: Goal Factoring
Introduction
Humans have these things that we call goals. They also take these things called actions. Ideally, a human takes actions that move the world closer to one of the human’s goals. You want your actions to be connected to your goals in this sense.
Usually, when an action is first introduced into your action repertoire, it has a very clear connection to your goal. However, once an action is introduced, it often tends to stick around. Sometimes, the action-goal connection doesn’t change, and so continuing to take that action is a good idea. Other times, the action-goal connection shifts, but you still continue to take that action.
The purpose of goal factoring is two fold. The first purpose is to evaluate the strength of the action goal connection for any given action. The second purpose is to find actions that have a stronger connection to your goals.
Cleaning your closet
Closets can have many things inside them. The closet I will discuss today contains all of your goals. However, you can’t just put stuff in a closet willy nilly, it must be organized in boxes. The boxes that you put your goals in are your actions.
We proceed as if we are cleaning a regular closet. First, we pick a box. Then we open the box. Sometimes, we realize that the box is way too big for the thing inside it, so we find a smaller box. Sometimes, we don’t even want the stuff, so we throw it away. Other times, we find that the stuff fits pretty well inside the box, so we leave it as it is. Goal factoring is the process of opening the action-box to find the goals inside.
In terms of action-goal connection, the first case corresponds to a case where the action is an ineffective way to achieve the goal. For example, suppose my goal is to stay up to date with current events and my action is browsing Reddit for hours a day. It seems evident that there are ways that will keep me both better informed about current events and take less time than browsing Reddit.
The second case corresponds to goals shifting as time passes. For example, I used to value having up-to-date information about Magic: the Gathering, resulting in me checking various MtG websites quite frequently. However, recently I discovered that I no longer really cared what was happening in the MtG world, yet I continued to check the websites.
The third case is when the action-goal connection remains strong. For example, I have a goal of not having my teeth fall out and I take the action of brushing my teeth. It seems to me that brushing my teeth is one of the best ways to not have your teeth fall out, so I continue to brush my teeth.
Steps
Here’s a diagram I stole from the CFAR handbook about a good visual way to follow these steps
Pick an action.
Write down all the goals that the action moves you towards
Many people have goals that aren’t quite socially desirable. It’s important to write these too.
For example, one of my goals for “going to the gym” is to become more attractive.
Completeness check: check if you’ve written down all the goals is to pretend that you already have everything you’ve written down in abundance. If you’ve written down all the goals, then you should feel no desire to perform the action any more.
Write down all the goals that the action moves you away from
Again, it’s important to write down everything, even stuff like “makes me look like a weirdo” and “don’t like talking to people”.
Removal check: check if you’ve written everything down by pretending that the action doesn’t move you away from any of those goals. If you’ve written everything down, then you should feel like taking the action is correct.
Remember that things like “takes time” are goals that almost all actions move you away from and that you should write those things down.
Decide if the goals you’ve written are crucial to that action.
This can be done by seeing how much your desire to take the action changes if you varied the magnitude of how much the action affected that goal.
In math language, a goal is crucial if the derivative of action desire w.r.t. action goal connection strength has large magnitude.
Example: “takes time” is probably not crucial to “brushing your teeth” because I would still brush my teeth if it took double the time.
Example: For me, “looking better” was not crucial to “going to the gym” because I would still go to the gym even if it made me look slightly worse.
Example : For me, “acquiring new experiences” was not crucial to “getting my ears pierced” because I wouldn’t extremely want to get my ears pierced if the experience was twice as unique.
Brainstorm other actions that achieve the goals you’ve written while avoiding the costs.
This is an exercise in [babbling] (https://www.lesswrong.com/s/pC6DYFLPMTCbEwH8W/p/i42Dfoh4HtsCAfXxL)
If the box you open has many goals inside, you can replace the single action with a lot of smaller action-boxes
Imagine taking those actions instead of the action you’re currently goal factoring. Are there any other goals that those actions move you away from? Are there any goals that those actions don’t move you towards?
Decide which set of actions to take, iterating (3) if necessary.
Example: Learning Chinese
My parents speak both Chinese and English. My extended family pretty much only speaks Chinese. My current level of Chinese is passable, but sorely lacking. As of 2 weeks ago, I had spent the past month or so studying Chinese for 10 minutes every day. Here’s what I goal factored:
Goals learning Chinese moved me towards:
Parental approval
Communicating with extended family
Want to be able to think in a different language
Social status boost from being bilingual
Career prospects increased from being bilingual
Goals learning Chinese moved me away from:
Takes time
Takes attention
I don’t like learning languages/memorizing things
I don’t like doing things I’m not good at
After considering which goals were crucial, the list ended up looking like:
Goals learning Chinese moved me towards:
Communicating with extended family
Want to be able to think in a different language
Goals learning Chinese moved me away from:
Takes time
Takes attention
Brainstorming ideas, I noted that “thinking in a different language” could be achieved by learning a non-Chinese language. In fact, it seemed like learning a language like ASL that uses a different channel of communication might be much better at achieving this goal than learning Chinese.
However, since my extended family pretty much only speaks Chinese, it seemed like “learning Chinese” was the best action to accomplish that particular goal. At this point I just had to weigh the time/attention it costs to learn Chinese versus how much I wanted to be able to communicate with my extended family.
This is what I ended up with:
This process is a lot like just writing a pro/cons list. Although plain pro/con lists are more useful than people give them credit for, I think that the crucial addition is trying to figure out different actions to take to get what you want.
Remember, the point of goal factoring is not to pick and action and convince yourself that it’s a good/bad action. Keep your bottom line empty.
Exercise
Pick an action and goal factor it. Places to look for actions that might be good to goal factor are actions that you started taking a long time ago, actions that take a lot of time, and actions that you don’t often think about because they’re very small. The latter case is relevant because lots of small actions can pile up and end up sucking away a lot of your time/attention.
Remember to build form
One way to think about applied rationality is trying to achieve your goals while staying agnostic about the strategy. Goal factoring is a tool that helps you do that.