Yeah, maybe I should have defined “recursive oversight” as “techniques that attempt to bootstrap from weak oversight to stronger oversight.” This would include IDA and task decomposition approaches (e.g. RRM). It wouldn’t seem to include debate, and that seems fine from my perspective. (And I indeed find it plausible that debate-shaped approaches could in fact scale arbitrarily, though I don’t think that existing debate schemes are likely to work without substantial new ideas.)
Yeah, maybe I should have defined “recursive oversight” as “techniques that attempt to bootstrap from weak oversight to stronger oversight.” This would include IDA and task decomposition approaches (e.g. RRM). It wouldn’t seem to include debate, and that seems fine from my perspective. (And I indeed find it plausible that debate-shaped approaches could in fact scale arbitrarily, though I don’t think that existing debate schemes are likely to work without substantial new ideas.)