IMO, reasonableness and epistemic competence are also key factors. This includes stuff like how effectively they update on evidence, how much they are pushed by motivated reasoning, how good are they at futurism and thinking about what will happen. I’d also include “general competence”.
(This is a copy of my comment made on your shortform version of this point.)
IMO, reasonableness and epistemic competence are also key factors. This includes stuff like how effectively they update on evidence, how much they are pushed by motivated reasoning, how good are they at futurism and thinking about what will happen. I’d also include “general competence”.
(This is a copy of my comment made on your shortform version of this point.)