Löb’s Theorem! Trust GiveWell because you evaluate it as trustworthy; not because it has evaluated itself!
That reduces self-evaluation to signalling. I suppose you could factor “they costly signal transparency” into your evaluation of GiveWell.
edit: Having read about their disciplinary action, I would like to revise my previous statement to “they extremely costly signal transparency”
Löb’s Theorem! Trust GiveWell because you evaluate it as trustworthy; not because it has evaluated itself!
That reduces self-evaluation to signalling. I suppose you could factor “they costly signal transparency” into your evaluation of GiveWell.
edit: Having read about their disciplinary action, I would like to revise my previous statement to “they extremely costly signal transparency”