I don’t understand. I have the information “I am an animal” and “I am a human”. If I start with “I am an animal” and update with “I am a human”, I get something different than if I start with “I am a human” and update with “I am an animal”. How do I get the correct answer?
Why do you end up with something different if you update in a different order? If you want a way to get the correct answer, work out why you do that and stop doing it!
Why do you end up with something different if you update in a different order?
I’d say it’s because I should be updating in both cases, rather than starting with “I am an animal” or “I am a human”. I should start with “I am conscious”, because I can’t not be, and then update from there.
I’m trying to show that picking reference classes arbitrarily leads to a contradiction, so SSA, as currently stated, doesn’t work. If it does, what other solution is there to that paradox?
Why do you end up with something different if you update in a different order? If you want a way to get the correct answer, work out why you do that and stop doing it!
I’d say it’s because I should be updating in both cases, rather than starting with “I am an animal” or “I am a human”. I should start with “I am conscious”, because I can’t not be, and then update from there.
I’m trying to show that picking reference classes arbitrarily leads to a contradiction, so SSA, as currently stated, doesn’t work. If it does, what other solution is there to that paradox?