I’d choose (b) without the amnesia because I do not cooperate with such scum and it be an interesting experience and test to figure out what to choose in similar cases.
I’d choose (b) without the amnesia because I do not cooperate with such scum and it be an interesting experience and test to figure out what to choose in similar cases.
Ming would not ask this, but—Are you sure you want to be tortured? Finding third options in bad scenarios is cool, but not if they’re strictly worse than the options already presented. This is like choosing suicide in Newcomb’s problem.
I’d choose (b) without the amnesia because I do not cooperate with such scum and it be an interesting experience and test to figure out what to choose in similar cases.
Ming would not ask this, but—Are you sure you want to be tortured? Finding third options in bad scenarios is cool, but not if they’re strictly worse than the options already presented. This is like choosing suicide in Newcomb’s problem.