I’d have thought from observation that quite a lot of human club is just about discussing the rules of human club, excess meta and all. Philosophy in daily practice being best considered a cultural activity, something humans do to impress other humans.
I dunno; “philosophy”, at least, doesn’t seem to be about discussing the rules of the human club, or maybe it’s discussing a very specific part of the rules (but then, so is Maths!). Family gossip and stand-up comedy seem much closer to “discussing the rules of the human club”.
I’d have thought from observation that quite a lot of human club is just about discussing the rules of human club, excess meta and all. Philosophy in daily practice being best considered a cultural activity, something humans do to impress other humans.
I dunno; “philosophy”, at least, doesn’t seem to be about discussing the rules of the human club, or maybe it’s discussing a very specific part of the rules (but then, so is Maths!). Family gossip and stand-up comedy seem much closer to “discussing the rules of the human club”.
Going meta is the quick win (in the social competition) for cultural discourse, though, c.f. postmodernism.
Most of this is done by people that don’t understand the rules of human club...