So many. I can’t limit it to one, but my top four would be “What if Mohammed had never been born?”, “What if Julian the Apostate had succeeded in stamping out Christianity?” and “What if Thera had never blown and the Minoans had survived?” and “What if Alexander the Great had lived to a ripe old age?”
The civilizations of the Near East were fascinating, and although the early Islamic Empire was interesting in its own right it did a lot to homogenize some really cool places. It also dealt a fatal wound to Byzantium as well. If Mohammed had never existed, I would look forward to reading about the Zoroastrian Persians, the Byzantines, and the Romanized Syrians and Egyptians surviving much longer than they did.
The Minoans were the most advanced civilization of their time, and had plumbing, three story buildings, urban planning and possibly even primitive optics in 2000 BC (I wrote a bit about them here). Although they’ve no doubt been romanticized, in the romanticized version at least they had a pretty equitable society, gave women high status, and revered art and nature. Then they were all destroyed by a giant volcano. I remember reading one historian’s speculation that if they’d lived, a man would’ve landed on the moon by 1 AD.
I don’t have such antipathy to Christianity that I’d want to prevent it from ever existing, but it sure did give us 2000 odd years of boring religion. Julian the Apostate was a Roman emperor who ruled a few reigns after Constantine and tried to turn back the clock, de-establish Christianity, and revive all the old pagan cults. He was also a philosopher, an intellectual, and by most accounts a pretty honest and decent guy. He died after reigning barely over a year, from a spear wound incurred in battle. If he’d lived, for all we know the US could be One Nation Under Zeus (or Wodin, or whoever) right now.
As for Alexander the Great, he was just plain nifty. I think I heard he was planning a campaign against Carthage before he died. If he’d lived to 80, he could’ve conquered all Europe, North Africa, and Western Asia, and have unified the whole western world under a dynasty of philosopher-kings dedicated to spreading Greek culture and ideas. Given a few more years, he might also have solved that whole “successor” issue.
Given that Alexander was one of the most successful conquerors in all of history, he almost certainly benefited from being extremely lucky. If he had lived longer, therefore, he would have probably experienced much regression to the mean with respect to his military success.
Of course, once you are already the most successful conqueror alive you tend to need less luck. You can get by on the basic competence that comes from experience and the resources you now have at your disposal. (So long as you don’t, for example, try to take Russia. Although even then Alexander’s style would probably have worked better than Napoleon’s.)
The civilizations of the Near East were fascinating, and although the early Islamic Empire was interesting in its own right it did a lot to homogenize some really cool places.
As did the Christian culture before them. And the original Roman Empire before that. And Alexander’s Hellenistic culture spread by the fragments of his mini-empire. And the Persian empires that came and went in the region...
So many. I can’t limit it to one, but my top four would be “What if Mohammed had never been born?”, “What if Julian the Apostate had succeeded in stamping out Christianity?” and “What if Thera had never blown and the Minoans had survived?” and “What if Alexander the Great had lived to a ripe old age?”
The civilizations of the Near East were fascinating, and although the early Islamic Empire was interesting in its own right it did a lot to homogenize some really cool places. It also dealt a fatal wound to Byzantium as well. If Mohammed had never existed, I would look forward to reading about the Zoroastrian Persians, the Byzantines, and the Romanized Syrians and Egyptians surviving much longer than they did.
The Minoans were the most advanced civilization of their time, and had plumbing, three story buildings, urban planning and possibly even primitive optics in 2000 BC (I wrote a bit about them here). Although they’ve no doubt been romanticized, in the romanticized version at least they had a pretty equitable society, gave women high status, and revered art and nature. Then they were all destroyed by a giant volcano. I remember reading one historian’s speculation that if they’d lived, a man would’ve landed on the moon by 1 AD.
I don’t have such antipathy to Christianity that I’d want to prevent it from ever existing, but it sure did give us 2000 odd years of boring religion. Julian the Apostate was a Roman emperor who ruled a few reigns after Constantine and tried to turn back the clock, de-establish Christianity, and revive all the old pagan cults. He was also a philosopher, an intellectual, and by most accounts a pretty honest and decent guy. He died after reigning barely over a year, from a spear wound incurred in battle. If he’d lived, for all we know the US could be One Nation Under Zeus (or Wodin, or whoever) right now.
As for Alexander the Great, he was just plain nifty. I think I heard he was planning a campaign against Carthage before he died. If he’d lived to 80, he could’ve conquered all Europe, North Africa, and Western Asia, and have unified the whole western world under a dynasty of philosopher-kings dedicated to spreading Greek culture and ideas. Given a few more years, he might also have solved that whole “successor” issue.
Given that Alexander was one of the most successful conquerors in all of history, he almost certainly benefited from being extremely lucky. If he had lived longer, therefore, he would have probably experienced much regression to the mean with respect to his military success.
Of course, once you are already the most successful conqueror alive you tend to need less luck. You can get by on the basic competence that comes from experience and the resources you now have at your disposal. (So long as you don’t, for example, try to take Russia. Although even then Alexander’s style would probably have worked better than Napoleon’s.)
As did the Christian culture before them. And the original Roman Empire before that. And Alexander’s Hellenistic culture spread by the fragments of his mini-empire. And the Persian empires that came and went in the region...