Interesting position! I can’t speak for James, but I want to engage with this. Let’s pretend, for the scope of this thread, that I made the statement about the proper role of skepticism.
I’m happy to endorse your wording. I agree it’s more precise to talk about “claims” than “things” in this context.
Quick communication check. When you say “increased” you’re implying at least two distinct levels of skepticism. From your assertion, I gather that difficult-to-measure claims like “there exist good leaders, people who can improve the performance of the rest of their team” will face your higher level of skepticism.
Could you give me an example of a claim that faces your lower level of skepticism?
When you say “increased” you’re implying at least two distinct levels of skepticism.
Well, I’m actually treating scepticism as a continuous variable, let’s say defined on non-negative real numbers for simplicity, where 0 means “I Believe!” and some sufficiently high number means “You’re lying”.
Could you give me an example of a claim that faces your lower level of skepticism?
“It’s raining outside”
“This thing weights five pounds”
“Free-falling objects start to accelerate by about 9.8 m/s/s”
Interesting position! I can’t speak for James, but I want to engage with this. Let’s pretend, for the scope of this thread, that I made the statement about the proper role of skepticism.
I’m happy to endorse your wording. I agree it’s more precise to talk about “claims” than “things” in this context.
Quick communication check. When you say “increased” you’re implying at least two distinct levels of skepticism. From your assertion, I gather that difficult-to-measure claims like “there exist good leaders, people who can improve the performance of the rest of their team” will face your higher level of skepticism.
Could you give me an example of a claim that faces your lower level of skepticism?
Well, I’m actually treating scepticism as a continuous variable, let’s say defined on non-negative real numbers for simplicity, where 0 means “I Believe!” and some sufficiently high number means “You’re lying”.
“It’s raining outside”
“This thing weights five pounds”
“Free-falling objects start to accelerate by about 9.8 m/s/s”