Mhm, I do think that sometimes happens and I wish more of those places would say “The rule is the moderator shall do whatever they think reasonable.” That’s basically my moderation rule for like, my dinner parties, or the ~30 person discord I mostly use to advertise D&D games.
But uh, I also suspect “The moderators shall do whatever they want” (and the insinuation that the moderators are capricious and tyrannical) is a common criticism leveled when clearness is sacrificed and the user disagrees with a moderation call.
Imagine a forum with two rules. “1. Don’t say false things, 2. don’t be a jerk.” It would not surprise me at all to hear Bob the user saying that he was being perfectly reasonable and accurate, the other user Carla was lying and being a jerk, and the mod just did whatever they wanted and banned Bob. Maybe the rule was secretly “The moderators shall do whatever they want.” But maybe the rule wasn’t clear, the moderator made a judgement call, and the correct tradeoff is happening. It’s really, really hard to legislate clear rules against being a jerk. Even the ‘false things’ line has a surprising amount of edge cases!
Mhm, I do think that sometimes happens and I wish more of those places would say “The rule is the moderator shall do whatever they think reasonable.” That’s basically my moderation rule for like, my dinner parties, or the ~30 person discord I mostly use to advertise D&D games.
But uh, I also suspect “The moderators shall do whatever they want” (and the insinuation that the moderators are capricious and tyrannical) is a common criticism leveled when clearness is sacrificed and the user disagrees with a moderation call.
Imagine a forum with two rules. “1. Don’t say false things, 2. don’t be a jerk.” It would not surprise me at all to hear Bob the user saying that he was being perfectly reasonable and accurate, the other user Carla was lying and being a jerk, and the mod just did whatever they wanted and banned Bob. Maybe the rule was secretly “The moderators shall do whatever they want.” But maybe the rule wasn’t clear, the moderator made a judgement call, and the correct tradeoff is happening. It’s really, really hard to legislate clear rules against being a jerk. Even the ‘false things’ line has a surprising amount of edge cases!