A while back, I was having a discussion with a friend (or maybe more of a friendly acquaintance) about linguistic profiling. It was totally civil, but we disagreed. Thinking about it over lunch, I noticed that my argument felt forced, while his argument seemed very reasonable, and I decided that he was right, or at least that his position seemed better than mine. So, I changed my mind. Later that day I told him I’d changed my mind and I thought he was right. He didn’t seem to know how to respond to that. I’m not sure he even thought I was being serious at first.
Have other people had similar experiences with this? Is there a way to tell someone you’ve changed your mind that lessens this response of incredulity?
Sometimes saying why you changed your mind can help. In more detail than “his position seemed better than mine”. But sometimes it takes doing some action that is in line with the new idea in order for other people to think you may be serious.
Another thing that may help is to wait some time before telling the person. “Later that day” makes it seem like a quick turnaround. Waiting until the next day to say something like “I’ve had some time to think about it, and I think you were right about X” might make more sense to the other person and lessen the incredulity.
Also, it depends on what your past history has been with this person, and what they have observed in your behaviour.
It happened to me only with people who were extremely, unreasonably cynical about people’s rationality in the first place (including their own). People who couldn’t update on the belief of people being unable to update on their beliefs. There’s an eerie kind of consistency about these people’s beliefs, at least for that much one can give them credit...
You have to engage in some extra signaling of having changed your own mind; just stating it wouldn’t be as convincing.
A while back, I was having a discussion with a friend (or maybe more of a friendly acquaintance) about linguistic profiling. It was totally civil, but we disagreed. Thinking about it over lunch, I noticed that my argument felt forced, while his argument seemed very reasonable, and I decided that he was right, or at least that his position seemed better than mine. So, I changed my mind. Later that day I told him I’d changed my mind and I thought he was right. He didn’t seem to know how to respond to that. I’m not sure he even thought I was being serious at first.
Have other people had similar experiences with this? Is there a way to tell someone you’ve changed your mind that lessens this response of incredulity?
Sometimes saying why you changed your mind can help. In more detail than “his position seemed better than mine”. But sometimes it takes doing some action that is in line with the new idea in order for other people to think you may be serious.
Another thing that may help is to wait some time before telling the person. “Later that day” makes it seem like a quick turnaround. Waiting until the next day to say something like “I’ve had some time to think about it, and I think you were right about X” might make more sense to the other person and lessen the incredulity.
Also, it depends on what your past history has been with this person, and what they have observed in your behaviour.
It happened to me only with people who were extremely, unreasonably cynical about people’s rationality in the first place (including their own). People who couldn’t update on the belief of people being unable to update on their beliefs. There’s an eerie kind of consistency about these people’s beliefs, at least for that much one can give them credit...
You have to engage in some extra signaling of having changed your own mind; just stating it wouldn’t be as convincing.