If this is true then a larger need-set would lead to more negative motivation due to there being more ways for something we think we need to be taken away from us.
Yes, exactly.
So the solution is for us to give up those “needs” in the need-set that aren’t actually needed for us to do what must be done, yes? We might believe that we need a cushy mattress to sleep on, a netflix account to entertain us, and a wardrobe of clothes to wear. If we simply satisfy these needs by acquiring all these things then we don’t really become happy because now we’re just afraid of losing it all. On the other hand, if we see that these “needs” are not literal needs at all, and we actually deflate our need-set, then we become happy.
I broadly agree. Though I would add that those things could still be (positive motivation) wants afterwards, which one pursues without needing them. I’m not advocating for asceticism.
Also, while I agree that you get more happiness by having fewer negative motives, being run by positive motives is not 100% happiness. One can still experience disappointment if one wants access to Netflix, and it’s down for maintenance one day. However, disappointment is still both more hedonic than fear and promotes a more measured reaction to the situation.
So the solution is for us to give up those “needs” in the need-set that aren’t actually needed for us to do what must be done, yes? We might believe that we need a cushy mattress to sleep on, a netflix account to entertain us, and a wardrobe of clothes to wear. If we simply satisfy these needs by acquiring all these things then we don’t really become happy because now we’re just afraid of losing it all. On the other hand, if we see that these “needs” are not literal needs at all, and we actually deflate our need-set, then we become happy.
Would you agree?
I broadly agree. Though I would add that those things could still be (positive motivation) wants afterwards, which one pursues without needing them. I’m not advocating for asceticism.
Also, while I agree that you get more happiness by having fewer negative motives, being run by positive motives is not 100% happiness. One can still experience disappointment if one wants access to Netflix, and it’s down for maintenance one day. However, disappointment is still both more hedonic than fear and promotes a more measured reaction to the situation.