I wasn’t trying to argue, just explain what appears to be the general consensus stance around here.
You seem to be using a lot of definitions differently than everyone else and this leads to misunderstandings. If I’ve got them right, perhaps the truth you are missing is this phrased using your definitions this: “Nothing other than an FAI has any morality. All intelligences, in all the multiverse, that are not deliberately made by humans to be otherwise, are crazy, in such a way it’ll remain so no matter how intelligent and powerful it gets.”
Any nonhuman AI is much closer to the category of evolution, or a stone, than it is to a human.
I wasn’t trying to argue, just explain what appears to be the general consensus stance around here.
I’m not very concerned about consensus views unless they are supported by good arguments.
You seem to be using a lot of definitions differently than everyone else
I believe that I am using definitions that are standard for the world at large, if not to LW.
“Nothing other than an FAI has any morality. All intelligences, in all the multiverse, that are not deliberately made by humans to be otherwise, are crazy, in such a way it’ll remain so no matter how intelligent and powerful it gets.”
I wasn’t trying to argue, just explain what appears to be the general consensus stance around here.
You seem to be using a lot of definitions differently than everyone else and this leads to misunderstandings. If I’ve got them right, perhaps the truth you are missing is this phrased using your definitions this: “Nothing other than an FAI has any morality. All intelligences, in all the multiverse, that are not deliberately made by humans to be otherwise, are crazy, in such a way it’ll remain so no matter how intelligent and powerful it gets.”
Any nonhuman AI is much closer to the category of evolution, or a stone, than it is to a human.
I’m not very concerned about consensus views unless they are supported by good arguments.
I believe that I am using definitions that are standard for the world at large, if not to LW.
Does “nothing other than an AI” include humans?