Seriously: of course anyone trying to offer an actual careful assessment will say something like “one of the greatest” or “arguably the greatest” or something. As you’ll see if you follow all my links above or search the web yourself, one very common practice is to say “widely regarded as the greatest” :-). Personally I rate him well above Sullivan and Holst and roughly equal with Elgar and RVW. I don’t know enough Ferneyhough to have a useful opinion.
Well, yes; it seems that he really had a strong fanbase, mostly among his fellow musicians. But I think you may be underestimating the popularity of Elgar, Sullivan and RVW’s music (if not Ferneyhough’s). I mean, these might as well be household names among relevant audiences; you can’t really say the same for Britten. Now, if I had to mention gay composers who are genuinely notable for their musical output, I’d say Lully and (most obviously) Tchaikovsky.
Decca, some guy writing for the New York Phil, some guy writing for the Daily Telegraph, etc.
Seriously: of course anyone trying to offer an actual careful assessment will say something like “one of the greatest” or “arguably the greatest” or something. As you’ll see if you follow all my links above or search the web yourself, one very common practice is to say “widely regarded as the greatest” :-). Personally I rate him well above Sullivan and Holst and roughly equal with Elgar and RVW. I don’t know enough Ferneyhough to have a useful opinion.
Well, yes; it seems that he really had a strong fanbase, mostly among his fellow musicians. But I think you may be underestimating the popularity of Elgar, Sullivan and RVW’s music (if not Ferneyhough’s). I mean, these might as well be household names among relevant audiences; you can’t really say the same for Britten. Now, if I had to mention gay composers who are genuinely notable for their musical output, I’d say Lully and (most obviously) Tchaikovsky.
I wasn’t talking about popularity. I’m sorry if I gave the wrong impression somehow.
(But yes, in terms of popularity Tchaikovsky certainly trumps Britten.)