Cool. I think I agree with the general spirit of making criticism that follows these guidelines.
I think the thing I’m having trouble parsing is how to translate typical critique into the style of Norm One. My current interpretation is something like, “Give small, incremental suggestions that they can actually implement, rather than larger, more nebulous vague-pointing things. (And if you want to do the nebulous thing, maybe only do that after giving the small incremental stuff and use the nebulous thing as more of a goalpost of what you intend by giving the incremental stuff.)”
Cool. I think I agree with the general spirit of making criticism that follows these guidelines.
I think the thing I’m having trouble parsing is how to translate typical critique into the style of Norm One. My current interpretation is something like, “Give small, incremental suggestions that they can actually implement, rather than larger, more nebulous vague-pointing things. (And if you want to do the nebulous thing, maybe only do that after giving the small incremental stuff and use the nebulous thing as more of a goalpost of what you intend by giving the incremental stuff.)”