FWIW, I asked Claude for its opinion today. It thought that new communication media/dynamics (A7, B14, B15 along with B8 & B9) were likely to blame, and that survivorship bias (A12) probably also plays a role.
Claude also suggested I add “The collapse of shared epistemic authorities” as another hypothesis, similar to but distinct from B15: “It’s not just that gatekeepers died; it’s that there’s no longer any institution or process that a broad majority accepts as capable of settling factual questions. When people disagree about facts, there’s no court of appeal. This makes all disagreement look like stupidity from the other side’s perspective, because there’s no shared standard by which to adjudicate it.”
FWIW, I asked Claude for its opinion today. It thought that new communication media/dynamics (A7, B14, B15 along with B8 & B9) were likely to blame, and that survivorship bias (A12) probably also plays a role.
Claude also suggested I add “The collapse of shared epistemic authorities” as another hypothesis, similar to but distinct from B15: “It’s not just that gatekeepers died; it’s that there’s no longer any institution or process that a broad majority accepts as capable of settling factual questions. When people disagree about facts, there’s no court of appeal. This makes all disagreement look like stupidity from the other side’s perspective, because there’s no shared standard by which to adjudicate it.”