There is a distinction, and you just gave it—some things are defined by their processes, and some things are not. Imagine instantaneously reducing something to an arbitrarily low temperature and leaving it that way forever as a substitute for stopping time, and see if the thing still counts as the same thing (this rule of thumb is not guaranteed to apply in all cases).
A frozen human body is not a human. It’s the corpse of a now-defunct human (will stay this way forever, so no cryonic restoration). So, the life—a process—is part of the definition of ‘human’. BUT since it was done instantaneously you could say it’s a corpse with a particular terminal mental state.
A trombone or triangle that’s reduced to epsilon kelvins is just a cold trombone or triangle.
A computer remains a computer, but it ceases to have any role-based identities like ’www.lesswrong.com′ or 230.126.52.85 (to name a random IP address). But, like the corpse, you can say it has a memory state corresponding to such roles.
Very interesting answer, thank you. So, for those things not defined by processes, is it unproblematic to talk about their being more or less real in terms of reality fluid?
Well, we haven’t exactly nailed down the ultimate nature of this magical reality fluid, but I don’t think that whether you define an object by shape or process changes how the magical reality fluid concept applies.
There is a distinction, and you just gave it—some things are defined by their processes, and some things are not. Imagine instantaneously reducing something to an arbitrarily low temperature and leaving it that way forever as a substitute for stopping time, and see if the thing still counts as the same thing (this rule of thumb is not guaranteed to apply in all cases).
A frozen human body is not a human. It’s the corpse of a now-defunct human (will stay this way forever, so no cryonic restoration). So, the life—a process—is part of the definition of ‘human’. BUT since it was done instantaneously you could say it’s a corpse with a particular terminal mental state.
A trombone or triangle that’s reduced to epsilon kelvins is just a cold trombone or triangle.
A computer remains a computer, but it ceases to have any role-based identities like ’www.lesswrong.com′ or 230.126.52.85 (to name a random IP address). But, like the corpse, you can say it has a memory state corresponding to such roles.
Very interesting answer, thank you. So, for those things not defined by processes, is it unproblematic to talk about their being more or less real in terms of reality fluid?
Well, we haven’t exactly nailed down the ultimate nature of this magical reality fluid, but I don’t think that whether you define an object by shape or process changes how the magical reality fluid concept applies.
Alright, thanks for your time, and for correcting me on the MWI point. I found this very interesting and helpful.