Perhaps. But Moody did defer to Dumbledore, keeping Moody totally in the dark doesn’t seem like a plausible option, and Harry explained to McGonagall in chapter 14 that he had enough common sense to seek out the appropriate experts in situations like this (or discovering Salazar’s Chamber).
Perhaps. But Moody did defer to Dumbledore, keeping Moody totally in the dark doesn’t seem like a plausible option, and Harry explained to McGonagall in chapter 14 that he had enough common sense to seek out the appropriate experts in situations like this (or discovering Salazar’s Chamber).