The parent comment currently stands at positive karma and negative agreement, but the comments on it seem to be saying “what you are saying is true but not exactly relevant or not the most important thing”—which would seem to suggest the comment should have negative or low karma but positive agreement instead.
On this evidence, I suspect voters and commenters may have different ideas; any voters want to express the reasons for their votes?
The parent comment currently stands at positive karma and negative agreement, but the comments on it seem to be saying “what you are saying is true but not exactly relevant or not the most important thing”—which would seem to suggest the comment should have negative or low karma but positive agreement instead.
On this evidence, I suspect voters and commenters may have different ideas; any voters want to express the reasons for their votes?