Alice, who is 10 years old: “Ah, I am about to be hit by a car, I should make sure this doesn’t happen else I’ll never get to live the rest of my life!”
Bob: “But have you considered that in the future you might get hit by another car? Or get cancer? Or choke on an olive? Current human life expectancy is around 80 years which means later on you’ll very likely die from something else. So I wouldn’t say your life is at stake right now.”
I don’t understand how this new analogy is supposed to apply to the argument, but if I wanted to modify the analogy to get my point across, I’d make Alice 90 years old. Then, I’d point out that, at such an age, getting hit by a car and dying painlessly genuinely isn’t extremely bad, since the alternative is to face death within the next several years with high probability anyway.
I don’t understand how this new analogy is supposed to apply to the argument, but if I wanted to modify the analogy to get my point across, I’d make Alice 90 years old. Then, I’d point out that, at such an age, getting hit by a car and dying painlessly genuinely isn’t extremely bad, since the alternative is to face death within the next several years with high probability anyway.