I’m sorry for that magnitude of misunderstanding, and will try to clarify it upfront in the post, but a large part of my argument is about why the principles of RSPs are not good enough, rather than the specific implementation (which is also not sufficient though, and which I argue in “Overselling, underdelivering” is one of the flaws of the framework and not just a problem that will pass).
You can check Section 3 for why I think that the principles are flawed, and Section 1 and 2 to get a better sense of what better principles look like.
Regarding the timeline, I think that it’s unreasonable to expect major framework changes over less than 5 years. And as I wrote, if you think otherwise, I’d love to hear any example of that happening in the past and the conditions under which it happened.
I do think that within the RSP framework, you can maybe get better but as I argue in Section 3, I think the framework is fundamentally flawed and should be replaced by a standard risk management framework, in which we include evals.
Thanks for your comment.
I’m sorry for that magnitude of misunderstanding, and will try to clarify it upfront in the post, but a large part of my argument is about why the principles of RSPs are not good enough, rather than the specific implementation (which is also not sufficient though, and which I argue in “Overselling, underdelivering” is one of the flaws of the framework and not just a problem that will pass).
You can check Section 3 for why I think that the principles are flawed, and Section 1 and 2 to get a better sense of what better principles look like.
Regarding the timeline, I think that it’s unreasonable to expect major framework changes over less than 5 years. And as I wrote, if you think otherwise, I’d love to hear any example of that happening in the past and the conditions under which it happened.
I do think that within the RSP framework, you can maybe get better but as I argue in Section 3, I think the framework is fundamentally flawed and should be replaced by a standard risk management framework, in which we include evals.