The up-vote treatment significantly increased the probability of up-voting by the first viewer by 32% over the control group … Uptreated comments were not down-voted significantly more or less frequently than the control group, so users did not tend to correct the upward manipulation. In the absence of a correction, positive herding accumulated over time.
Huh. That sounds exactly like the results from my little LW experiment: http://www.gwern.net/Anchoring