It makes a huge difference whether the dust speck choices add up or not. If they do, OrphanWilde’s objection applies and the only path to survival is to be tortured.
If they don’t, so each one of me gets one dust speck total, then dust specks for sure. All of the copies of me (whether there are one or 3^^^3 of us) are experiencing what amounts to a choice between individually being dust-specked or individually being tortured. We get what we ask for either way, and no one else is actually impacted by the choice.
There’s no need to drag average utilitarianism in.
Computational theory of identity so some large number of exact copies of the same individual experiencing the same thing don’t sum, they only count as once instance?
That too. But my reasoning holds in the more general case, where instead of it being 3^^^3 copies of me, it was 3^^^3 entities from the pool of people who would choose specks.
It makes a huge difference whether the dust speck choices add up or not. If they do, OrphanWilde’s objection applies and the only path to survival is to be tortured.
If they don’t, so each one of me gets one dust speck total, then dust specks for sure. All of the copies of me (whether there are one or 3^^^3 of us) are experiencing what amounts to a choice between individually being dust-specked or individually being tortured. We get what we ask for either way, and no one else is actually impacted by the choice.
There’s no need to drag average utilitarianism in.
Computational theory of identity so some large number of exact copies of the same individual experiencing the same thing don’t sum, they only count as once instance?
That too. But my reasoning holds in the more general case, where instead of it being 3^^^3 copies of me, it was 3^^^3 entities from the pool of people who would choose specks.