Is there some particular harm in bumping posts with substantial edits?
A rule like “don’t exploit a bug to bump your own posts, period” is much easier to enforce than if you allow exceptions for a fuzzy category of posts with “substantial edits”—posters might be tempted to use that to attract extra attention, or suspect others of doing that.
More specifically, the “landscape” is already moving enough with back-and-forths between main and discussion, and people renaming their posts; if people start bumping their posts up keeping track of what I read and where there is interesting conversation will be even more of a hassle.
That makes sense, and also matches my prior intuitions as to what it might be. Thank you.
I think part of the problem is that I was operating on a mindset of a smaller / lower traffic group where this kind of promotion is has a relatively minor effect and less power to annoy others (as opposed to drawing them into a conversation that they might actually like).
In a larger userbase like we’re currently seeing for Discussion, ensuring fun for all participants is more dependent on these kinds of self-filtering rules/norms being followed more strictly. I’ve commented in open thread expressing a desire for more subreddits, and will be more careful in Discussion.
A rule like “don’t exploit a bug to bump your own posts, period” is much easier to enforce than if you allow exceptions for a fuzzy category of posts with “substantial edits”—posters might be tempted to use that to attract extra attention, or suspect others of doing that.
More specifically, the “landscape” is already moving enough with back-and-forths between main and discussion, and people renaming their posts; if people start bumping their posts up keeping track of what I read and where there is interesting conversation will be even more of a hassle.
That makes sense, and also matches my prior intuitions as to what it might be. Thank you.
I think part of the problem is that I was operating on a mindset of a smaller / lower traffic group where this kind of promotion is has a relatively minor effect and less power to annoy others (as opposed to drawing them into a conversation that they might actually like).
In a larger userbase like we’re currently seeing for Discussion, ensuring fun for all participants is more dependent on these kinds of self-filtering rules/norms being followed more strictly. I’ve commented in open thread expressing a desire for more subreddits, and will be more careful in Discussion.