If only claims (1) and (2) had been critically analyzed in detail on Less Wrong or the SIAI website I would find your comment compelling. Given that such analysis has not been made or released, I interpret Eliezer’s response as an argument by authority.
If only claims (1) and (2) had been critically analyzed in detail on Less Wrong or the SIAI website I would find your comment compelling. Given that such analysis has not been made or released, I interpret Eliezer’s response as an argument by authority.