I would guess that these disagreements, particularly (a) and (c), come down to relatively deep worldview differences (related to the debate over “Pascal’s Mugging”) that I will probably write more about in the future.
How does Givewell plan to deal with the possibility that people who come to Givewell looking for charity advice may have a variety of worldviews that impact their thinking on this?
How does Givewell plan to deal with the possibility that people who come to Givewell looking for charity advice may have a variety of worldviews that impact their thinking on this?