It occurs to me to wonder if Dementors=death can be tested experimentally by bringing a dementor into the Hall of Prophecy. Of course, if the Dementor isn’t attacked by orbs about death, that could mean that there aren’t any death-prophecies, they only react to Death rather than a single wound in the world, or something else; but if a dementor does run into a prophecy that is about death, that would determine that the hall recognizes them as death for the purposes of prophecies.
(Alternatively: if prophecies about something different, such as fear / depression / whatever show up, that’d be pretty strong evidence against.)
I think the orbs only come to people (things that think, and can make decisions), and it’s not clear Dementors pass that test. (In particular, Harry leans against that hypothesis. He’s certainly not infallible, but he’s basically the best expert on the subject whose thoughts we have access to.)
Otherwise prophecies mentioning things like life, wands and clothes would attack everyone.
It occurs to me to wonder if Dementors=death can be tested experimentally by bringing a dementor into the Hall of Prophecy. Of course, if the Dementor isn’t attacked by orbs about death, that could mean that there aren’t any death-prophecies, they only react to Death rather than a single wound in the world, or something else; but if a dementor does run into a prophecy that is about death, that would determine that the hall recognizes them as death for the purposes of prophecies.
(Alternatively: if prophecies about something different, such as fear / depression / whatever show up, that’d be pretty strong evidence against.)
I think the orbs only come to people (things that think, and can make decisions), and it’s not clear Dementors pass that test. (In particular, Harry leans against that hypothesis. He’s certainly not infallible, but he’s basically the best expert on the subject whose thoughts we have access to.)
Otherwise prophecies mentioning things like life, wands and clothes would attack everyone.