Did the Nigerians giving feedback collectively agree a poem isn’t valid if it doesn’t rhyme?
OA has declined to ever say. It is possible that the Scale et al contractors have done something weird like say that all poems must rhyme no matter what the prompt says, but I consider this unlikely, and if they were that incompetent, I’d expect to see more pathologies like this.
In light of the Twitter kerfuffle over Paul Graham criticizing ChatGPTese tics like the use of the verb “delve”, which made Nigerian/Black Twitter very angry (and becoming living embodiments of Muphry’s law), as apparently ‘delve’ and other ChatGPTese tells are considered the height of style in Nigerian English, I’ve had to reconsider this.
It may be that a lot of the ChatGPT linguistic weirdness is in fact just the data labelers being weird (and highly overconfident), and the rest of us simply not being familiar enough with English idiolects to recognize ChatGPTese as reflecting specific ones. Further, after seeing the arguments Graham’s critics have been making, now I’m not so sure that the labelers wouldn’t be doing something as narrow-minded & incompetent as penalizing all non-rhyming poetry—if you are not very good at English yourself, you can easily recognize rhymes and ballad formal correctness, but not good non-rhyming poetry, so...
In light of the Twitter kerfuffle over Paul Graham criticizing ChatGPTese tics like the use of the verb “delve”, which made Nigerian/Black Twitter very angry (and becoming living embodiments of Muphry’s law), as apparently ‘delve’ and other ChatGPTese tells are considered the height of style in Nigerian English, I’ve had to reconsider this.
It may be that a lot of the ChatGPT linguistic weirdness is in fact just the data labelers being weird (and highly overconfident), and the rest of us simply not being familiar enough with English idiolects to recognize ChatGPTese as reflecting specific ones. Further, after seeing the arguments Graham’s critics have been making, now I’m not so sure that the labelers wouldn’t be doing something as narrow-minded & incompetent as penalizing all non-rhyming poetry—if you are not very good at English yourself, you can easily recognize rhymes and ballad formal correctness, but not good non-rhyming poetry, so...