Seems like the main difference is that you’re “counting up” with status and “counting down” with genetic fitness.
There’s partial overlap between people’s reproductive interests and their motivations, and you and others have emphasized places where there’s a mismatch, but there are also (for example) plenty of people who plan their lives around having & raising kids.
There’s partial overlap between status and people’s motivations, and this post emphasizes places where they match up, but there are also (for example) plenty of people who put tons of effort into leveling up their videogame characters, or affiliating-at-a-distance with Taylor Swift or LeBron James, with minimal real-world benefit to themselves.
And it’s easier to count up lots of things as status-related if you’re using a vague concept of status which can encompass all sorts of status-related behaviors, including (e.g.) both status-seeking and status-affiliation. “Inclusive genetic fitness” is a nice precise concept so it can be clear when individuals fail to aim for it even when acting on adaptations that are directly involved in reproduction & raising offspring.
Seems like the main difference is that you’re “counting up” with status and “counting down” with genetic fitness.
There’s partial overlap between people’s reproductive interests and their motivations, and you and others have emphasized places where there’s a mismatch, but there are also (for example) plenty of people who plan their lives around having & raising kids.
There’s partial overlap between status and people’s motivations, and this post emphasizes places where they match up, but there are also (for example) plenty of people who put tons of effort into leveling up their videogame characters, or affiliating-at-a-distance with Taylor Swift or LeBron James, with minimal real-world benefit to themselves.
And it’s easier to count up lots of things as status-related if you’re using a vague concept of status which can encompass all sorts of status-related behaviors, including (e.g.) both status-seeking and status-affiliation. “Inclusive genetic fitness” is a nice precise concept so it can be clear when individuals fail to aim for it even when acting on adaptations that are directly involved in reproduction & raising offspring.