You haven’t shown that they are producing inconsistent theories in their published work. The result only shows that, like scientists, individual philosophers can’t live up to their own cognitive standards in certain situations.
This is true. But it is significant evidence that they are inconsistent in their work too, absent an objective standard by which their work can be judged.
You haven’t shown that they are producing inconsistent theories in their published work. The result only shows that, like scientists, individual philosophers can’t live up to their own cognitive standards in certain situations.
This is true. But it is significant evidence that they are inconsistent in their work too, absent an objective standard by which their work can be judged.