Thanks for the post! I wrote up something along similar lines but ended up declining to cross-post it. Basically: I largely agree with you, I have yet more quibbles, and I’m a little more pessimistic about your upsides.
I may have put extra focus on the upsides in an attempt to be more even-handed. The things that I say about the upsides are true and I do believe them but they aren’t really the meat of the paper.
I’m realizing that sharing writing and thoughts is largely appreciated. The EA forum has explicit events to try getting people to publish their drafts. In that spirit I decided to post this here, and I’m glad that some people are finding it valuable.
Thanks for the post! I wrote up something along similar lines but ended up declining to cross-post it. Basically: I largely agree with you, I have yet more quibbles, and I’m a little more pessimistic about your upsides.
I may have put extra focus on the upsides in an attempt to be more even-handed. The things that I say about the upsides are true and I do believe them but they aren’t really the meat of the paper.
I’m realizing that sharing writing and thoughts is largely appreciated. The EA forum has explicit events to try getting people to publish their drafts. In that spirit I decided to post this here, and I’m glad that some people are finding it valuable.