Sure, there are facts about what preferences would best enable the emergence of an intergalactic civilization. I struggle to see these as moral facts.
There’s a misunderstanding/miscommunication here. I wasn’t suggesting “what preferences would best enable the emergence of an intergalactic civilization” are moral facts. Instead I was suggesting in that scenario that building an intergalactic civilization may require a certain amount of philosophical ability and willingness/tendency to be motivated by normative facts discovered through philosophical reasoning, and that philosophical ability could eventually enables that civilization to discover and be motivated by moral facts.
In other words, it’s [high philosophical ability/sophistication causes both intergalactic civilization and discovery of moral facts], not [discovery of “moral facts” causes intergalactic civilization].
Well, i struggle to articulate what exactly we disagree on, because I find no real issue with this comment. Maybe i would say “high philosophical ability/sophistication causes both intergalactic civilization and moral convergence.”? I hesitate to call the result of that moral convergence “moral fact,” though I can conceive of that convergence.
There’s a misunderstanding/miscommunication here. I wasn’t suggesting “what preferences would best enable the emergence of an intergalactic civilization” are moral facts. Instead I was suggesting in that scenario that building an intergalactic civilization may require a certain amount of philosophical ability and willingness/tendency to be motivated by normative facts discovered through philosophical reasoning, and that philosophical ability could eventually enables that civilization to discover and be motivated by moral facts.
In other words, it’s [high philosophical ability/sophistication causes both intergalactic civilization and discovery of moral facts], not [discovery of “moral facts” causes intergalactic civilization].
Well, i struggle to articulate what exactly we disagree on, because I find no real issue with this comment. Maybe i would say “high philosophical ability/sophistication causes both intergalactic civilization and moral convergence.”? I hesitate to call the result of that moral convergence “moral fact,” though I can conceive of that convergence.