For anyone who wants more, one of the earliest responses to Quine, Grice and Strawson’s “In Defense of a Dogma,” is here. I’m also quite fond of Carnap’s reply to Quine in Carnap’s volume in the Library of Living Philosophers, but I don’t think that’s online anywhere.
For anyone who wants more, one of the earliest responses to Quine, Grice and Strawson’s “In Defense of a Dogma,” is here. I’m also quite fond of Carnap’s reply to Quine in Carnap’s volume in the Library of Living Philosophers, but I don’t think that’s online anywhere.