This is an interesting idea. The main qualm I have is with spam- am I going to spend my precious karma on hiding jewelry advertisements?- but otherwise it seems the right disincentive for being critical.
Well, ideally if a moderator deleted your comment as spam you’d get your karma back; or maybe downvoting shouldn’t be used as a way to deal with spam (there is a “report” button for that).
This is an interesting idea. The main qualm I have is with spam- am I going to spend my precious karma on hiding jewelry advertisements?- but otherwise it seems the right disincentive for being critical.
Well, ideally if a moderator deleted your comment as spam you’d get your karma back; or maybe downvoting shouldn’t be used as a way to deal with spam (there is a “report” button for that).