I agree, most personality traits can be aquired, even if they are heavily selected against genetically. But it isn’t always desirable to do so, even if these habits are considered socially useful.
For instance, I’m naturally a night person, but I developed through self discipline, over the course of holding down a standard 9-5 job, a habit of ‘early rising’, even on weekends. This had, over a period of time, a seriously negative effect on my health and cognitive ability. Switching to a job that allowed me to revert to a more natural sleep cycle was a much better solution for me and my employers.
It’s important to do a cost-benefit analysis when attempting to change behaviour, sometimes a change of environment is more feasible.
Agreed. Also, someone who has naturally strong self-control and feels guilty when they “slip up” can still develop a habit of not exercising and eating junk food. That doesn’t mean it’s a useful habit.
Note: I think the “natural sleep cycle” problem might have more to do with social expectations than innate tendencies. For example, I work mostly mornings, including several shifts a week that start at 6 am. My sleep schedule is set at 11pm-7am, although I can fall asleep as early as 9:30 if I know I have to be up at 5:00, and I have a lot of trouble staying up for, say, parties. I miss out on most of the reputation-related benefits of actually going out with people my age...when I do, I’m usually a tired wreck by midnight. It seems to me that anyone who wanted to make more of an effort than I do to be social would necessarily sacrifice the ability to easily wake up early.
I agree, most personality traits can be aquired, even if they are heavily selected against genetically. But it isn’t always desirable to do so, even if these habits are considered socially useful.
For instance, I’m naturally a night person, but I developed through self discipline, over the course of holding down a standard 9-5 job, a habit of ‘early rising’, even on weekends. This had, over a period of time, a seriously negative effect on my health and cognitive ability. Switching to a job that allowed me to revert to a more natural sleep cycle was a much better solution for me and my employers.
It’s important to do a cost-benefit analysis when attempting to change behaviour, sometimes a change of environment is more feasible.
Agreed. Also, someone who has naturally strong self-control and feels guilty when they “slip up” can still develop a habit of not exercising and eating junk food. That doesn’t mean it’s a useful habit.
Note: I think the “natural sleep cycle” problem might have more to do with social expectations than innate tendencies. For example, I work mostly mornings, including several shifts a week that start at 6 am. My sleep schedule is set at 11pm-7am, although I can fall asleep as early as 9:30 if I know I have to be up at 5:00, and I have a lot of trouble staying up for, say, parties. I miss out on most of the reputation-related benefits of actually going out with people my age...when I do, I’m usually a tired wreck by midnight. It seems to me that anyone who wanted to make more of an effort than I do to be social would necessarily sacrifice the ability to easily wake up early.