Are you kidding me? What is your discount rate? Not flipping that coin is absurd.
Not absurd. Not everything is “maximize your utilty.” Some people care about the trajectory they’re on together with other people. Are parents supposed to just leave their children? Do married people get to flip a coin that decides for both of them, or do they have to make independent throws (or does only one person get the opportunity)?
Also, there may be further confounders so that the question may not tell you exactly what you think it tells you. For instance, some people will flip the coin because they’re unhappy and the coin is an easy way to solve their problems one way or another—suicide feels easier if someone else safely does it for you and if there’s a chance of something good to look forward to.
“The best possible life” for me pretty much includes “everyone who I care about is totally happy”?
Okay, I can see it being meant that way. (Even though, if you take this logic further, you could, as an altruist, make it include everything going well for everyone everywhere.) Still, that’s only 50% of the coinflip.
And parents certainly do dangerous risky things to provide better future for their children all the time.
Yeah, that’s true. I could even imagine that parents are more likely to flip coins that say “you die for sure but your kids get a 50% chance of the perfect life.” (Especially if the kids are at an age where they would be able to take care of themselves even under the bad outcome.)
Not absurd. Not everything is “maximize your utilty.” Some people care about the trajectory they’re on together with other people. Are parents supposed to just leave their children? Do married people get to flip a coin that decides for both of them, or do they have to make independent throws (or does only one person get the opportunity)?
Also, there may be further confounders so that the question may not tell you exactly what you think it tells you. For instance, some people will flip the coin because they’re unhappy and the coin is an easy way to solve their problems one way or another—suicide feels easier if someone else safely does it for you and if there’s a chance of something good to look forward to.
“The best possible life” for me pretty much includes “everyone who I care about is totally happy”?
And parents certainly do dangerous risky things to provide better future for their children all the time.
Okay, I can see it being meant that way. (Even though, if you take this logic further, you could, as an altruist, make it include everything going well for everyone everywhere.) Still, that’s only 50% of the coinflip.
Yeah, that’s true. I could even imagine that parents are more likely to flip coins that say “you die for sure but your kids get a 50% chance of the perfect life.” (Especially if the kids are at an age where they would be able to take care of themselves even under the bad outcome.)